Search
Leave a Message
By providing your contact information to Stephanie Schwed, your personal information will be processed in accordance with Stephanie Schwed's Privacy Policy. By checking the box(es) below, you consent to receive communications regarding your real estate inquiries and related marketing and promotional updates in the manner selected by you. For SMS text messages, message frequency varies. Message and data rates may apply. You may opt out of receiving further communications from Stephanie Schwed at any time. To opt out of receiving SMS text messages, reply STOP to unsubscribe.
Thank you for your message. I will be in touch with you shortly.
Explore My Properties
A broad estate lawn in Palm Beach Gardens overlooking a separate fairway, with mature trees and the edge of a shaded stucco home.

Bay Hill Estates Gets a Private Course Behind Its Acre Lots

November 19, 2026

In March 2026, a one-acre home in Bay Hill Estates sold for $1,180,000. Palm Beach County Property Appraiser records list it under Stonewal Estates, the community's earlier name. The same deed history shows the house selling for $525,000 in February 2015. For comparison, the median single-family sale price across all of Palm Beach County was $656,000 in September 2026, according to the Miami Realtors report for that month.

That sale happened six months before PGA National announced that the golf course running through the neighborhood would reopen as Triple Stick Golf Club, a private, members-only club. A buyer looking at Bay Hill Estates this winter should treat the house and the course as two purchases. The lot and the open view behind it come with the deed. The right to play the course has always been sold separately by the resort's owner, and the new owner has now made it a limited, members-only club. A buyer who keeps those two decisions apart will make a better offer on either one.

The neighborhood has never owned its course

Bay Hill Estates is a gated community of about 250 single-family homes on one-acre lots, with a 24-hour staffed gatehouse at 9100 Bay Hill Drive off Northlake Boulevard. Its history was messy. The Phase 1 property owners association records that the original articles date to about December 1983, and that from 1983 through 1994 the original developer went through multiple name changes and several bankruptcies. Starting in 1995, lots were sold out of bankruptcy court to a number of different builders, and in 1997 the lot owners took control of the board. Because the lots went to many builders, the homes along Bay Hill Drive were not built from one developer's plan book. For a buyer, that means two houses on the same street can differ widely in construction, layout and condition.

The golf course has a separate history. It opened in November 1984 as Stonewall Golf Club and became part of PGA National in 1988, as Golf Course Architecture reported when the redesign was announced. The association's own records describe Phase I as 118 acres of common property, 266 acres of platted lots and 146 acres of golf course. The association does not own the course. Instead, the course carries the association membership rights and obligations of 6.5 homes. Homeowners have never been required to buy a PGA golf or social membership. As a courtesy, PGA National has allowed Bay Hill Estates residents to buy the same paid memberships that PGA National residents can buy.

So a Bay Hill Estates deed has always included the view of the fairways and the distance from neighbors that the course creates. It has never included the right to play. That arrangement is what makes Triple Stick a pricing question for buyers.

What the new owner built

Henderson Park completed its purchase of PGA National Resort in January 2025, in a joint venture with Salamander and South Street Partners. On September 16, 2026, the resort announced Triple Stick Golf Club, located within Bay Hill Estates and following the routing of the former Estates Course. In that release, Rob Duckett, Henderson Park's managing director of golf and club operations, said the owners were "proud to introduce a new private golf opportunity to improve upon the previous Estates Course offering."

Love Golf Design did the redesign. According to the release, major earthmoving was avoided, every existing lake was left undisturbed, and native pines and oaks were added along the wide playing corridors. The new course has Dye-style features such as railroad-tie bulkheads, flat-bottomed bunkers framed in tufted native grasses, and waste areas of sand, shell and screenings. It plays as a par 70. The old Estates Course, as the association still describes it, was a par 72 with wide fairways and generous setbacks from the surrounding homes. Since the routing, the lakes and the land stayed where they were, the view from most back terraces should keep its basic shape. The planting and the bunkers will look different.

Access is the bigger change. The Triple Stick club page describes a private, non-equity membership that includes the family: a spouse or partner and children under 23. It covers Triple Stick plus the rest of PGA National's courses, racquet and fitness facilities, the spa and the dining venues. The page also says "Membership is intentionally limited" and mentions early membership promotions, but it publishes no prices. The release promises current PGA National Resort members a first look and exclusive options to add access. It says nothing about priority for people who live along the fairways. The course is scheduled to open in late fall 2026, and the 11,000-square-foot Peacock + Lewis clubhouse is expected in 2028.

The land is what the buyer is paying for

The appraiser's record for that house splits its value in a way that supports this reading. The land value was $265,000 for tax year 2022, rose to $365,000 for 2023, and has been $475,000 for each of 2024, 2025 and 2026. Over the same years, the improvement value moved within a narrow band and stood at $509,719 for 2026. The acre accounts for almost half of the appraiser's $984,719 total market value for 2026. This is a single parcel and a single sale, not a neighborhood median. Still, it shows where the value in this community sits. Buyers here pay for an acre of gated land with the course behind it, and the course part of that is open space they enjoy without owning it.

That makes the buying decision fairly simple. If the buyer wants the land, the gate and the open view, the purchase price covers all of it, and Triple Stick changes very little except for some new planting along the fairways. A buyer who wants to play the course is making a second decision with a different seller, priced by a club that sets its own terms and has not published them. The two decisions should be priced separately, and the second one is worth a conversation with the club's membership office before an offer goes in.

The September county figures give the timing context. Palm Beach County single-family homes went from listing to contract in a median of 43 days in September 2026, down from 51 days a year earlier, with 3.6 months of supply at the end of the month. Homes are moving a little faster than a year ago, so a buyer who waits for the membership terms before writing an offer may find the house already under contract.

Weighing it against new construction in Avenir

The obvious new-construction comparison is Avenir, also in western Palm Beach Gardens, which is planned for 3,900 homes in total. In the APEX at Avenir neighborhood, GL Homes lists its Pinnacle collection from the $960s and its Summit collection from $1.4 million. At those prices, a new house sits in the same range as the March resale in Bay Hill Estates.

What separates the two is the age of the house, the size of the lot and how the golf works. Avenir is a planned community with its own district, the Avenir CDD, established January 5, 2017. Bay Hill Estates has an acre of land, a house built sometime after 1995 by one of several builders, and an association that describes its fees as low, covering cable, internet, the staffed gate and the common grounds. The course behind those lots now belongs to a private club that a buyer can join or skip. We compared recurring costs across the city in our look at Palm Beach Gardens fee structures, and a full side-by-side of any two addresses starts with each one's current annual bills.

Construction ahead, inside and outside the gate

Triple Stick's clubhouse is expected in 2028, so construction work will continue inside Bay Hill Estates for some time after the course reopens. The plan includes a dining-focused clubhouse with covered outdoor seating, set within a redesigned practice facility with an expanded driving range and a dedicated short-game area. Buyers looking at lots near the practice area or the clubhouse site should consider how close they will be to that work and to the activity once the clubhouse is open.

Outside the gate, the Florida Department of Transportation's $54 million I-95 at Northlake Boulevard interchange project is scheduled to begin construction in November 2026 and finish in late 2029. The work covers Northlake from Military Trail to Silverthorne Drive and includes ramp and Northlake widening plus a fourth through-lane under I-95. Bay Hill Drive opens onto Northlake, so anyone who drives east to I-95 will pass through that work zone for most of the next three years. Buyers should test that drive at the times they would actually make it.

This post is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice, so please confirm the costs that apply to your own purchase with the right professional.

We review the parcel record, the age and condition of the house, the renovation scope and the club decision as separate questions so your offer reflects what you are actually buying. Stephanie Schwed can walk the lot with you and help you put each part of the decision in order before you make an offer. Let's Connect.

Follow Us On Instagram